Threats to the Ridge Actions that should be taken to save the Ridge About the Shawangunk Ridge Coalition Media coverage about the Shawangunk Ridge Learn more about the environment of the Shawangunk Ridge Conservation efforts on the Shawangunk Ridge Recreation on the Shawangunk Ridge Maps of the Shawangunk Ridge Links to supporters and affiliated sites Search this site for information Contact information for the Shawangunk Ridge Coalition Return to our home page

Delicate Mushroom Incites Hudson Valley Tug of War
Mamakating Journal
By LISA W. FODERARO
March 1, 2006

MAMAKATING, N.Y. - On the face of it, mushrooms would seem to be just the kind of gentle industry that this scenic corner of Sullivan County would like to entice. After all, programs abound in the Hudson Valley to keep what little agriculture remains. But the mushroom operation envisioned for a parcel of land about 70 miles north of New York City is not a drowsy roadside farm, but what critics have called a high-tech agribusiness fortress.

A Japanese company, Yukiguni Maitake Manufacturing Corporation of America, wants to build a windowless building with a five-acre footprint that would produce 30 tons of maitake mushrooms daily. No one disputes that the plant would draw in hundreds of thousands of gallons of water a day from the aquifer beneath it to aid in the indoor growing process.

"The name of the company is manufacturing, and that's what they're doing: they're manufacturing mushrooms," said Eileen Haworth Weil, a retired professor of English and an opponent of the plant. "It will change the ambience of the town."

The parent company, Yukiguni Maitake, already has five such plants in Japan that together yield 120 tons of mushrooms a day. Eager to realize its first overseas venture, the company has tried to foster a market for maitakes in the United States by selling them to top chefs in New York.

The company says that its plant here will be absolutely clean, with no pesticides or manure used to cultivate the maitakes, which are large and leafy and prized for their nutty flavor. Indeed, they are actually grown in a mixture of sawdust, corn and oat bran.

Maitakes have long been popular in Japan and may possess cancer-fighting properties. Investigators at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center are trying to determine whether maitake extract can stimulate the immune system in a trial involving breast cancer patients.

When up and running, the $90 million operation, on 48 acres, would create 210 permanent jobs and generate more than $1 million a year in tax revenue for the town, county and local schools, according to Kazunori Kameyama, president and chief executive of Yukiguni Maitake Manufacturing.

"We are trying to come from Japan to the United States to spend money to make a healthful product, and we are not going to destroy the existing nature," Mr. Kameyama, a former banker, said in an interview in his Middletown, N.Y., office.

The town of Mamakating's zoning and planning boards signed off on the company's plans after an environmental review. The town's final approval is pending. But many there are not convinced, and an opposition movement is clouding the company's prospects as it awaits final site plan approval and a special-use permit.

Opponents say the building, which would rise to 80 feet at its highest point, would mar the area, which includes part of the Shawangunk Ridge - beloved by hikers and nature photographers, among others - and the Delaware & Hudson Canal Linear Park. Some worry that the plant will tax the aquifer during periods of drought.

They also criticize the town for not subjecting the company to a more rigorous environmental review. Mr. Kameyama, who had to address more than 20 environmental issues, scoffed at that idea.

Scores of signs proclaiming "No Mushroom Plant" have sprouted along roads and on the sides of barns. The Basha Kill Area Association, a local nonprofit group that protects the largest freshwater wetlands in southeastern New York, has filed a lawsuit against the town's planning board.

Another lawsuit was filed against the town's zoning board of appeals by a couple whose property abuts the Yukiguni land. Opponents even fielded a slate of candidates in last fall's local elections. The slate lost, but one candidate came within several votes of unseating the town supervisor.

Mr. Kameyama said the dissent has spawned its share of xenophobia. He was particularly chagrined when a local newspaper put the story on its front page with the headline "Mushroom Clouds" - which he said he read as a not-so-subtle reference to the American atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

"At the public meetings, I was told by some of the people to 'get out of my ancestor's land,' " Mr. Kameyama said. "We paid money for the property. Why should I be called an invader?"

Others, including town and county officials, support the plan, saying the town needs the jobs and the tax revenue.

Marc A. Baez, president and chief executive of the Sullivan County Partnership, a nonprofit economic development agency, called the opposition a "boisterous minority" that was "working to keep the community as it is." Charles E. Penna, the town supervisor, accused critics of waging a "misinformation campaign," spreading fear about the potential for odors and a plume of mist, which he called "nonissues."

Mr. Kameyama acknowledged that there would be a sawdust smell on the grounds of the plant, but said that it would not drift beyond the property. As for the mist that critics say could add humidity to an already foggy valley, he compared the puffs of steam that would rise from the rooftop to those of any commercial cooling system.

Mr. Penna is concerned about the plant's design, however, saying that he favors a rustic, Adirondack-style facade. "It has to blend in," he said.

But Mr. Kameyama said the design reflects the fact that mushrooms need a perfectly controlled environment. "You see windowless concrete buildings everywhere," he said, referring to big-box stores.

Like many fights over new development, this one has exposed class and economic tensions in the town. "We have an elitist group in this community," Mr. Penna said. "They hide behind being environmentalists. I wish they would come down to earth and realize that the commoners need jobs."

But critics say the jobs will be mostly low paying and insist that the fight is not about income, but about the future of this town of 11,000 residents.

"This is an extraordinarily beautiful area, and we are blessed with extraordinary resources," said Anita Altman, who has a weekend house here. "These guys are coming in to exploit it, and they will provide very little in return."

www.nytimes.com/2006/03/01/nyregion/01mushroom.html?_r=1&oref=slogin